I had got some of the repop ones on eBay about 4 years for around 350$ I believe not sure the manufacturer but I'm sure most repops are similar, but a few years later after sitting in the garage with no exposure to water or sun one had a couple small pits on it. So I don't think any repops are good as the originals but I would say if you find someone who take out gouges and dings out the originals they could have a good business and make good money!
Wait a minute, 350 bucks for repop headlight buckets. You can buy original restored for less than $40 ea on ebay or go to any swap and buy originals and restore them yourself.