If you are saying that any carb that was calibrated and tuned for 1970s gasoline is still as good for today's very, very different gasoline, I just have to disagree and have a question; How many Thermoquads have you tuned for today's gasoline with a wide band? Given the extremely limited availability of tuning parts, I can guess the answer. And most driving is done on the transitions anyway. Give us a quick detail on how to dial in those transitions. Hint: it takes drill bits.
EVERY original stock muscle car engine I have worked on can benefit from better timing curves and carb calibrations. EVERY ONE. That was true in 1975 and is even more true today. Preferring to run those old carbs untuned for today's realities is tantamount to preferring to run point ignitions over electronic ignitions. Will they run the car........yes they will. Are there better choices now......yes there are. The final choice comes down to what the owner's priorities and abilities are.
And I will make two more points; First, the Thermoquad was introduced in the first place to deal with emission issues, not necessarily to be the best carb for performance. And second, the ONLY high performance engine it was used on was the 340. Mopar even experimented with 6 barrels on the Hemi to deal with the changing emissions environment, but I have never read anything about Mopar experimenting with the Thermoquad for that application. Have you? I wonder WHY that was? Or why, with the huge flow capabilities of the Thermoquads did Mopar not experiment with replacing the triple Holleys on the 440 with one?
I have nothing against the AFBs, AVSs, or the Thermoquads. They have their place in our history. But using them today for most guys, makes as much sense as using early 70s blends of oils and saying they have had no trouble doing it. But just because a half century old product hasn't totally failed you, does not mean that there aren't simply better choices for us today.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with someone preferring to run a Thermoquad on their own ride for whatever reason. But generally recommending them to others is a completely different thing and should not be done in most instances.
.