The manual is 30 lbs lighter. You don't have parasitic drag on the motor from the pump. It is more turns from lock to lock. It is a pain to parallel park with. I prefer it at highway speeds. The power is easier to drive overall. I have an Challenger RT that came with 4 speed, manual steering, no heat or a/c. It is a fun car. I wouldn't change it. I'm working on a 69 Satellite convertible. It is a cruiser with power steering. I wouldn't change that either. What do you want to do with your car? Sounds like a weekend fun car. If so I would go with power. There are aftermarket boxes that solve most of the problems presented by both the factory manual and power steering. I plan to use the Borgeson power box in my convertible.